TORONTO – Three of Canada’s largest banks, driven by domestic growth, have soared in the stock market this year on a spate of acquisitions. At the same time, lenders with global ambitions have sagged on rising costs in foreign markets.
Shares of Royal Bank of Canada, CIBC, and National Bank have outperformed the broader TSX index’s 9.8% rise so far in 2024. National Bank was the top gainer with a 15.2% rise, followed by RBC with about 13.5% and CIBC with 10.9%.
The TSX banking index has advanced about 7.5%.
Shares of rivals that rely on overseas markets to increase revenue have fallen, led by Bank of Montreal with an 11.3% drop; followed by Toronto-Dominion Bank, down about 6%; and Bank of Nova Scotia with about 1%.
Among the winners, RBC was propelled by its acquisition of HSBC Canada this year and National Bank rose on its C$5 billion ($3.65 billion) proposal to buy Canadian Western Bank.
CIBC got a boost from its focus on digital banking and wealthy clients in Canada, and growing U.S. commercial accounts.
“It’s really a question of more risk appetite. The expansion within Canada, the east-west expansion, is a much lower risk proposition” than growth south of the border, said Ben Jang, a portfolio manager at Nicola Wealth, which holds shares in TD, RBC, and CWB.
However, Canada’s Big Six banks – four of which are among North America’s 10 largest – already control more than 90% of the domestic market.
Some sought growth abroad after the government quashed plans in 1998 to merge RBC and BMO, and TD Bank with CIBC. The push intensified with TD’s U.S. acquisition spree in the mid-2000s and BMO’s $16 billion purchase of regional U.S. lender Bank of the West in 2022.
Scotiabank expanded even further south, to the Caribbean, Mexico, Peru and Colombia, and other parts of Latin America.
However, the southward drive has encountered roadblocks. U.S. regulatory probes into TD’s anti-money laundering program have plagued the bank. In July, RBC Capital Markets analysts flagged faster credit deterioration at BMO than its U.S. peers.
Scotiabank last year laid out a plan to focus on the North American corridor. Its stock fell 3.4% on Monday after it announced a surprisingly aggressive move to buy a 14.9% stake in U.S. bank KeyCorp.
For Scotiabank, acquisitions have historically weighed on returns, National Bank analysts noted.
As markets get more crowded, new growth is more likely to come from wealth management or capital markets, which are typically more profitable than consumer banking, investors and analysts said.
“Banks that focus on Canadian banking supplemented with wealth and capital markets outperform banks that chase international banking growth,” analyst Nigel D’Souza at Veritas Investment Research said.
Compared with the Canadian market, U.S. personal and commercial banking generates a lower return on equity, and costs to retain deposits are high in competitive areas.
Investors betting on U.S. growth are better off owning shares of U.S. banks such as JP Morgan (NYSE: JPM), Fifth Third Bancorp (NASDAQ: FITB), and Regions Financial (NYSE: RF), which have larger returns on equity than Canadian lenders like BMO or TD with U.S. subsidiaries, D’Souza noted.
RBC and National Bank trade at 12 and 11 times forward earnings estimates, respectively, indicating higher growth expectations over the next 12 months than TD’s 9.5 and Scotiabank’s 9.2. BMO and CIBC have a forward price-to-earnings ratio of around 10 times.
JP Morgan trades at 12 times forward earnings and Bank of America at 11 times.
The S&P 500 banks index, which tracks the largest U.S. banks, has jumped nearly 16% this year.
Canada’s Big Six banks ended the second quarter with total deposits of $5.7 trillion, of which 21.8% came from the U.S., according to an analysis by financial data provider Wowa.ca.
When asked to comment, RBC, TD, Scotiabank, CIBC, and National Bank all pointed to financial statements for details on their foreign exposure. BMO declined to comment.
“We do know that (operating in the U.S.) is costlier. But for the Canadian banks it’s that added incremental revenue because our (Canada) market is already saturated,” said Maria-Gabriella Khoury, senior director at Fitch Ratings.
“Now it’s more along the lines of let’s see whose strategy works best.”
“They have got to think of something else right now. And I think shareholders recognize that the growth is just not there(overseas),” said John Zechner of J. Zechner Associates.
($1 = 1.3693 Canadian dollars)
(Source: ReutersReuters)
